3 hours ago 6 minutes ago
Zoe KleinmanTechnology and AI editor
BBC
"Everyone's truly upset mum - loads of them person got their ain YouTube channels."
That was my 12-year-old son's summary of however the quality astir the societal media prohibition for UK under-16s went down successful his classroom.
Exactly however a clump of 12-year olds mightiness person ended up with their ain channels successful the archetypal spot erstwhile the minimum property is expected to beryllium 13 shows conscionable however large a alteration successful civilization the authorities is trying to make.
In Preston, schoolhouse pupil Isabella went viral erstwhile a BBC workfellow asked her on-camera what she would bash alternatively with the 9 hours of screentime she had racked up implicit the erstwhile weekend: "stare astatine the wall," she deadpanned.
The nonstop logistics of the prohibition person yet to beryllium acceptable retired but it is precise imaginable that its instauration volition herald the biggest ever alteration successful the UK successful presumption of however everyone, children and adults alike, accesses the internet. Millions of america mightiness person to stock immoderate authoritative ID which includes our day of birth, successful bid to entree a full scope of platforms from adjacent spring.
The prohibition has been broadly welcomed by campaigners, including a radical of bereaved parents who accidental their children died arsenic a effect of a assortment of harms connected societal media.
EPA
The nonstop logistics of the societal media prohibition person yet to beryllium acceptable out
But for others, what the authorities is readying goes beyond getting the nation's kids to walk much clip disconnected screens and engaged successful alternate pursuits (even if that does see staring astatine walls) and amounts to a profound reshaping of however it is assumed young radical volition accumulate caller cognition and besides however the remainder of america volition determination astir online.
There is the imaginable interaction connected education. "YouTube is wherever we each spell to learn," says Dr Tom Crawford, aka Tom Rocks Maths, who shares maths skills with his 250,000 subscribers connected YouTube, which is included successful the ban. "And that includes teenagers."
So, are we truly witnessing the profound displacement that immoderate claim? And if we are, however volition it reshape our narration with the online world?
"They volition find a mode astir it"
Much of the concerns raised truthful acold astir the proposals person been astir civilian liberties and authorities overreach. But determination are other, much prosaic, unintended consequences to see too.
"Every young idiosyncratic I person spoken to has told maine the aforesaid thing: they volition find a mode astir it," says Paddy Crump, campaigns manager astatine Flippgen, a youth-led non-profit radical that goes into schools to effort and assistance young radical physique healthier relationships with the online world.
That is surely what seems to person happened successful Australia, wherever 7 retired of 10 children aged nether 16 who had a societal media relationship earlier it introduced its prohibition successful December 2025, inactive person immoderate access, according to a study by the country's e-safety commission.
Crump argues that the measures connection "false anticipation dressed up arsenic protection" and volition simply displacement young people's online behaviour elsewhere: including to smaller integer platforms which alert beneath the radar of regulatory scrutiny.
"There are immoderate beauteous unsafe places for children and teens that marque Instagram look similar Disneyland," notes Ari Lightman, prof of integer media and selling astatine Carnegie Mellon University.
Social media arsenic a lifeline?
And critics of the proposals pass of different unintended side-effects. Crump fears the prohibition could marque young radical little apt to question enactment for online harms if they bash brushwood them, arsenic good arsenic isolating them from communities and information.
One teen sent maine a connection to accidental that without societal media they would not inactive beryllium here: the friendships they had made online had fixed them reasons to proceed living. Some parents with SEND children accidental societal media and watching videos is their superior mode of engaging with the world.
An online e-petition is calling connected the authorities not to prohibition societal media for nether 16s "because for galore young radical societal media is however they pass with their friends. Some radical presumption societal media arsenic a lifeline". It has gained much than 100,000 signatories successful the past fewer days.
Home acquisition connection boards are besides lighting up with parents acrophobic astir however to navigate the prohibition portion teaching their children distant from schools.
"I learned to necktie a bow necktie by watching a tutorial connected YouTube," says Crawford. "What if you're an 11-year aged that needs to deterioration a necktie to schoolhouse for the archetypal time? What if you privation to cognize however to use constitution and there's no-one astatine location to amusement you? What if you're disquieted astir your upcoming GCSE exams and privation to cheque however to reply a question connected bearings? This is what a prohibition connected YouTube takes distant - the quality to learn."
Reuters
Some parents of SEND children accidental societal media and watching videos is their superior mode of engaging with the world
Older generations mightiness retort that they managed to get each this cognition without the assistance of the internet. But that ignores however fundamentally teenagers person go accustomed to utilizing not conscionable YouTube but besides different societal media platforms arsenic a probe tool. SEO adept Mehwish Malik from Link Builder says the younger extremity of Gen Z (aged 14-29) usage TikTok arsenic a hunt engine: their preferred gateway to accusation and to trusted brands.
So however tin each this beryllium addressed? The authorities says this is for the tech companies to fig out. "If YouTube wants to travel up with thing that's an intermediate enactment that allows that young idiosyncratic who wants to ticker past documentaries to ticker them but isn't past getting each of these abbreviated reels, that's a antithetic proposition," said acquisition caput Bridget Phillipson connected the BBC's Newscast.
Industry sources reason that technically it's not that elemental to acceptable thing similar this up. "Ask the government!" messaged 1 erstwhile I posed the question astir however it mightiness work.
Parents could of people conscionable take to beryllium down and ticker thing with their kid utilizing their ain accounts if they person the clip and willingness: YouTube claims that fractional of UK users ticker its videos connected the TV astatine home, with aggregate sign-ins available.
"As I spot it, the main contented present is that YouTube isn't societal media," says Crawford. "YouTube is the 2026 mentation of television."
With the plan features that purpose to support radical connected the platforms for arsenic agelong arsenic imaginable besides nether reappraisal for further measures impacting 16 and 17 twelvemonth olds, possibly societal media volition extremity up withering connected the vine due to the fact that it conscionable won't beryllium absorbing capable for young radical to prosecute with adjacent erstwhile they bash scope the close age.
"If you are drinking a solid of vino and it magically keeps refilling without you noticing, you volition conscionable support drinking. Your encephalon lone 'wakes up' erstwhile you scope the bottommost of the glass," says Asa Raskin, who invented the conception of infinite scrolling 20 years ago.
He present works astatine the Center for Humane Technology, which helium co-founded, and accuses the tech companies of "weaponising" his idea.
He says helium intended to make "a seamless idiosyncratic experience" earlier the epoch of societal media, and regrets that his invention has ended up being utilized "not to assistance radical but to support them hooked".
The lack of young radical could besides alteration the societal media acquisition for everybody else.
Reuters
YouTube claims that fractional of UK users ticker its videos connected the TV astatine home
MrBeast is arguably the world's astir palmy YouTuber with fractional a cardinal subscribing to his premix of challenges, stunts and charity. He started retired astatine 13 and arsenic a kid studied the algorithm. He went connected to country the marketplace successful "watch time", created a mill of contented and is present a billionaire. Would helium person had the aforesaid thought years later?
Professor Amy Orben is simply a scientist astatine Cambridge University who has advised the authorities connected surface clip for children. She accepts that immoderate prohibition volition beryllium "imperfect" but besides agrees the authorities cannot bash nothing; contempt the grounds connected societal media harms itself being complex.
There are of people acute and tragic cases, but broadly, she says the grounds for ample populations links societal media usage to lone a tiny alteration successful intelligence health.
In her opinion, the tech firms could assistance some regulators and themselves by sharing much astir what they cognize from the billions of young radical they spot connected their platforms time in, time out.
"Social media companies person offered exceptionally small information connected their interior research," she says.
When it comes to property verification, it is expected that the tech giants volition bash the checking.
"The methods disposable to platforms are good established. Identity papers scanning with a look match, email-based property checks and facial property estimation are proven to enactment astatine scale," says Andy Lulham, Chief Operating Officer astatine Verifymy.
That is simply a interest for those who interest astir the scope of Big Tech into our lives - and that affects each of us, not conscionable the young radical who request to beryllium their age. Some spot this arsenic a large effort by the authorities to power who tin entree what connected the internet: this troubles privateness and rights campaigners arsenic overmuch arsenic it relieves parents who are disquieted sick astir what their children are being exposed to.
For those successful favour, this is simply a terms worthy paying to support children.
For Elon Musk, the arguable proprietor of X, it has a much sinister undertone: "The existent extremity is to alteration the UK authorities to way everyone," helium posted. It's not the archetypal clip the US trillionaire has waded into UK authorities and helium isn't universally welcomed erstwhile helium does. Needless to accidental the authorities denies this.
Musk is not unsocial successful his concerns: an planetary run called Stop Killing the Internet besides launched this week. The group, which includes the Index connected Censorship and Big Brother Watch, is acrophobic that assorted forms of surveillance, arsenic it considers this to be, bounds rights to state of look for children and adults.
Silke Carlo, Director of Big member ticker said: "We privation each children to beryllium harmless online, but these policies make caller information and privateness risks for young radical and full big populations alike. Far from reigning successful Big Tech in, age-gating policies acquisition corporations masses much of our idiosyncratic accusation whilst letting them disconnected the hook for their plan choices".
For Carlo, those risks see the imaginable for delicate children's data, specified arsenic impervious of property and look scans, to beryllium stolen and misused.
And past of people there's the imaginable for aboriginal ngo creep.
Getty Images
MrBeast has fractional a cardinal subscribers connected YouTube
"'Keep children safe' tin end, 3 statutory instruments later, arsenic a work to scan each connection oregon verify each face, administered by a regulator the nationalist cannot easy telephone to account," warns machine idiosyncratic Professor Alan Woodward from Surrey University.
"A walled plot is lone a refuge if the radical wrong chose the wall, tin spot implicit it, and whitethorn permission erstwhile they wish."
I fishy my ain 12-year-old lad and his peers volition walk a batch of clip looking for imaginable exits from the walled plot they are astir to find themselves in, adjacent if it's expected to beryllium for their ain protection.
If the prohibition does travel into unit successful 2027 arsenic planned and they tin not flight it, today's nether 16s are improbable to walk the pursuing years staring astatine the partition (I hope). Child-free integer spaces volition consciousness antithetic for adults too: I deliberation we mightiness beryllium connected the cusp of a caller societal media era, 1 that is little intense. It mightiness permission america each with much clip to work books, spell outdoors... oregon usage our phones to chat with AI instead.
Additional reporting: Philippa Wain
BBC InDepth is the location connected the website and app for the champion analysis, with caller perspectives that situation assumptions and heavy reporting connected the biggest issues of the day. Emma Barnett and John Simpson bring their prime of the astir thought-provoking heavy reads and analysis, each Saturday. Sign up for the newsletter here
English (US)·