Clark County District Judge Pete Thunell heard arguments Monday on the water district's motion to dismiss a lawsuit seeking to recover millions in excessive-use charges from high-consuming homeowners. Thunell questioned both sides but deferred his ruling, saying he will decide before a Dec. 7 court date whether the case can move forward as a class action involving tens of thousands of customers.
The suit targets the district's tiered penalty structure, which charges $9 per 1,000 gallons used over a monthly limit that varies by season. The program applies only to Las Vegas Valley Water District customers, not those in North Las Vegas, Henderson or Boulder City. Attorneys for the plaintiffs allege the district has collected at least $96 million since 2023, funds the district says are used exclusively for conservation programs.
Water district attorney Chad Fears argued the charges are reasonable and that the plaintiffs are among the valley's highest water users seeking to subsidize their consumption. He described one household as having large lots with a private lazy river, several pools and waterfalls. "You want to use that much water? You want to have shrubs and trees that are not desert appropriate? That is fine. We're not making that illegal," Fears said. "You just have to pay for that water."
Fears also contended that customers' recourse for disputing the fees is voting out the district's governing board, the Clark County Commission. Homeowners' attorney Sam Castor called that remedy unsatisfactory, arguing there should be a direct way for individuals to challenge the fines.
The penalty program is a first-of-its-kind effort to curb Colorado River use. Nevada holds the smallest allocation among the seven basin states, and state officials have warned of an existential threat if the federal government cuts the state's share by 71 percent, a scenario floated in the river's 10-year operating plan.
Sources: Las Vegas Review-Journal
Original reporting: Las Vegas Review-Journal →



English (US)·