Billion-dollar water rights ruling could ‘plunge the state into crisis,’ lawyer says

39 minutes ago 2 min read 3
⚡ Sincity Press Brief

A district judge ruled Nevada's groundwater management decisions constituted an unconstitutional taking of private property in the Coyote Springs case, potentially exposing taxpayers to over $1 billion in damages.

Billion-dollar water rights ruling could ‘plunge the state into crisis,’ lawyer says

A ruling by District Judge Mark Denton in the long-running Coyote Springs water rights case could reshape Nevada water law and expose state taxpayers to more than $1 billion in damages. Denton ruled Wednesday that the state engineer's groundwater management decisions, which effectively halted plans for a massive development northeast of Las Vegas, amounted to an "unconstitutional taking" of private property. A jury will now determine the compensation owed; the developer is seeking $600 million plus interest and attorneys' fees, which state attorney Laura FitzSimmons said totals well over $1 billion.

"This decision is unfathomable," FitzSimmons said. "No court in any state or anywhere in this country has ever found that a water permit is a property right that requires compensation." Debbie Leonard, a Northern Nevada water attorney not involved in the case, called the ruling chaotic. "It throws everything I've known and understood about Western water law into total chaos," she said. "It upends everything. It's really hard for me to get my head around a decision like this and not just be appalled."

Attorneys for the developers and property rights advocates argue such concerns are overblown. The land, owned by California developers Albert and Thomas Seeno, was once envisioned as a city twice the size of Summerlin with up to 160,000 homes, golf courses, and hotel-casinos straddling Clark and Lincoln counties. Attorney Mark Hutchison, representing the Seenos, said Thursday his clients have no plans to revive that vision. "The answer is it's just solar," Hutchison said. "And right now, it's just an option agreement."

Nevada energy regulators granted conditional approval in mid-October for an 8,177-acre, 1,200-megawatt solar project proposed by Reno-based Estuary Power, pending further state, Lincoln County, and Federal Aviation Administration approvals. If built, it could become one of the nation's largest solar farms. NV Energy has entered a power-purchase agreement for 600 megawatts from the project's first phase, pending state regulatory approval, to buy power for 25 years and battery storage for 20 years.

Sources: Las Vegas Review-Journal

Original reporting: Las Vegas Review-Journal →
Up nextCommerce Street set to temporarily reopen as work continues on Charleston Storm Drain project