2 hours ago 
Image source, Jacob King/PA Wire
Sarah Andrews (left) and Sarah Hawkins (right) some mislaid their daughters owed to maternity failings
ByLaura Hammond and George TorrEast Midlands
More than 500 mothers and babies suffered avoidable harm oregon died owed to failings astatine a "toxic" infirmary trust, a landmark maternity reappraisal has found.
Led by elder midwife Donna Ockenden, the enquiry - the largest of its benignant successful NHS past - recovered leaders astatine Nottingham University Hospitals (NUH) NHS Trust knew determination were superior issues astatine its maternity section going backmost years, but failed to instrumentality action.
When her reappraisal was published connected Wednesday, it besides revealed antithetic attraction whitethorn person altered the result for 260 babies who died oregon were harmed.
Ockenden said: "This is simply a study astir however a strategy failed, and what it costs erstwhile it fails. It costs lives, futures and families, everything."
More connected the Nottingham maternity scandal
About 2,500 families and much than 800 members of unit contributed to the review, which started successful 2022.
But Ockenden said determination were "gaps" successful knowledge, due to the fact that immoderate elder leaders declined to prosecute with her review.
The study said 66 erstwhile and existent elder colleagues were approached by the main enforcement of the trust, of which 37 came guardant and 35 were interviewed.
However, experts connected the reappraisal concluded determination were "potentially avoidable" outcomes relating to 444 maternity cases examined up to May 2025, alongside 76 neonatal cases.
All of these 520 cases were graded arsenic 2 oregon 3 for harm, with people 3 representing "significant concerns" and people 3 "major concerns" implicit care.
Grade 2 represents sub-optimal care, successful which antithetic absorption mightiness person made a quality to the outcome, people 3 is wherever antithetic absorption would reasonably beryllium expected to person made a difference.
The refusal of immoderate absorption to prosecute successful the reappraisal led to the authorities announcing that the scope of Martha's Rule would beryllium extended successful a bid to boost accountability and information for mothers and babies.
Other measures see ensuring NHS unit - past and contiguous - who garbage to prosecute with upcoming maternity reviews are compelled to springiness evidence, or look up to 2 years successful prison, though it is not yet clear however this volition beryllium enforced.
Image source, Jacob King/PA Wire
Donna Ockenden presented the findings of her maternity reappraisal connected Wednesday
Ockenden unveiled the findings of her reappraisal astatine the Crowne Plaza edifice successful Nottingham, successful beforehand of a fig of bereaved and affected families.
Her reappraisal squad told the BBC that antithetic attraction whitethorn person altered the result for 260 babies who died oregon were harmed. Of that number, 155 babies died portion 105 suffered superior wounded owed to substandard care.
Ockenden said galore of the problems elaborate successful her study had been known astir astatine NUH since "at slightest 2010".
These see insufficient staffing, and the inability of unit to transportation retired basal and often mandatory training.
She besides highlighted a "persistent nonaccomplishment to perceive to and judge mothers and fathers" - arsenic good arsenic a nonaccomplishment to investigate, and truthful larn from, mistakes.
Ockenden said women's consent was not sought during labour and immoderate enactment from unit was astatine times "cruel".
Women successful labour were told to "pull themselves together" portion different submission from a parent recalled however she was told to "wait their turn" arsenic determination was "other women they had to sort".
Watch: During her reappraisal presentation, Ockenden paid tribute to the families involved
Ockenden said the work astatine NUH present was "not wherever it was, but it is not yet wherever it needs to be".
Drawing her presumption to a close, she said: "We beryllium it to each parent and babe whose unspeakable experiences are recorded to beryllium definite these failures present are ne'er repeated.
"Time for talking and reflecting has passed this needs corporate action, sustained enactment and renewed confidence.
"The families of Nottingham person shown bonzer determination and courageousness successful the look of devastating consequences which has marked their lives - they did this truthful what happened to them does not hap to anyone else."
Speaking during a property league aft Ockenden's presentation, Dr Jack Hawkins - whose girl Harriet was stillborn astatine Nottingham City Hospital successful 2016 - said actions for learning identified successful the reappraisal "must beryllium treated with the utmost seriousness".
He said: "Some of the themes identified are ones that we had nonstop and idiosyncratic acquisition of - our concerns were dismissed and not acted upon - we were not told the truth, adjacent aft death.
"The infirmary often failed to support our loved ones safe."
Sarah Hawkins - Harriet's parent and a whistleblower of the maternity ungraded - said she felt fto down by those who cared for her.
Sarah was a elder physiotherapist and Jack was a advisor doctor.
She said: "We dedicated our careers to the NHS - I thought I would spot my colleagues - I was debased risk. Then to beryllium treated during my six-day labour similar I was, I couldn't compute it.
"After Harriet died - the cover-up was horrific, we knew this due to the fact that we knew the system."
Image source, Jacob King/PA Wire
Gary and Sarah Andrews, whose girl Wynter died aft 23 minutes successful 2019
During the property conference, Jack called for a statutory nationalist inquiry.
Meanwhile, Health Secretary James Murray said "no options are disconnected the table" erstwhile questioned connected the contented successful the House of Commons.
Murray, who met families taking portion successful the maternity review past week, had been addressing Ockenden's report.
He said: "I felt numb aft proceeding the extent of their pain.
"I felt adjacent much fig erstwhile I considered however galore families not successful the country went done specified trauma too, and the forgotten children who survived but lived with the consequences of failings successful maternity attraction each day."
Murray, who said helium would beryllium speaking to NUH main enforcement Anthony May adjacent week, added the "government volition act".
After the work of Ockenden's report, it was announced that Martha's Rule - which guarantees patients the close to an urgent accelerated reappraisal of their attraction - is to beryllium rolled retired to maternity settings.
Image source, Jacob King/PA Wire
NUH president Nick Carver (left) and spot main enforcement Anthony May heard Ockenden outline her findings
In effect to the review, NUH president Nick Carver and main enforcement May issued an unfastened letter, addressed to "the radical and communities of Nottinghamshire".
In it, they apologised "unreservedly to the women and families who person suffered harm, loss, trauma oregon distress portion receiving attraction successful our services".
The missive added: "We recognise that spot is earned done actions, not words. We know, also, that families and the wider nationalist volition justice america not by what we accidental today, but by what we bash next.
"The reappraisal makes wide that portion improvements person been made, determination is inactive much to do. We volition instrumentality clip to bespeak connected the study with humility, honesty and determination.
"At the aforesaid time, we volition enactment with families connected a meaningful apology due to the fact that we cognize it is important to them that this is reflective of the findings of the review, and our committedness to lasting improvement."
Get successful touch
Tell america which stories we should screen successful Nottingham
English (US)·