Nevada taxpayers could owe hundreds of millions of dollars to the developers of Coyote Springs, a never-built city in Southern Nevada, after a judge ruled the state unconstitutionally took their water rights. Clark County Judge Mark Denton found that the actions and inactions of the State Engineer's office caused an unconstitutional taking of private property belonging to Coyote Springs Investment. A jury will now decide the amount of damages, with attorneys for the developers seeking $600 million plus interest and attorney fees.
The case is considered a first-of-its-kind test of whether water rights constitute property protected by the Nevada Constitution's prohibition on government taking property without compensation. Judge Denton wrote that the State Engineer's order combining water basins into the Lower White River Flow System and imposing an 8,000 acre-foot pumping cap was "unprecedented and thus unforeseeable." The Nevada Supreme Court affirmed the engineer's authority to combine basins in a 2024 decision.
Developer attorney Mark Hutchison, a former Republican lieutenant governor, said the ruling is about accountability for how the State Engineer's office interacted with his client over many years. The Nevada Attorney General's office is reviewing the ruling and had no further comment. Judge Denton is retiring at the end of the year, and it is unclear which judge will oversee the damages phase, which Hutchison expects to conclude early next year.
Coyote Springs was originally conceived by lobbyist Harvey Whittemore, who purchased the land in 1998. The Seeno family of California developers are now the sole owners. The project was planned to be twice the size of Summerlin with golf courses and hotel-casinos, but not a single home has been built. The developers have maintained water rights for years by watering a golf course on the property. The area is home to the endangered Moapa dace, a tiny fish native to the Muddy River.
Sources: Las Vegas Review-Journal
Original reporting: Las Vegas Review-Journal →



English (US)·